Ads Advisor in Google Ads: a practitioner's take

It isn't a strategic advisor. It's a salesperson holding the keys to your wallet. But if you know which of its tips belong in the trash, you'll win where others just burn budget.

Ads Advisor in Google Ads isn't a technological breakthrough. It's a change in how users talk to the system. And that distinction matters.

Zarezerwuj termin na bezpłatne naprawcze konsultacje.

Book a free call

Ads Advisor

The problem isn’t that Ads Advisor „works badly”

Ads Advisor (beta) is a conversational analysis layer in Google Ads, built on Gemini and agents. Officially, it’s there to help analyze performance, troubleshoot problems and optimize campaigns. And under certain conditions it does that surprisingly well.

The problem isn’t that Ads Advisor „works badly”.

The problem is that it works well within a narrow range, and its answers are easy to overrate if you don’t understand where they come from and where they stop.

I’m writing this as someone who tested the tool not in theory but on real accounts, both lead generation and e-commerce, where every decision costs money.

Google describes Ads Advisor as an agentic, conversational mode in Google Ads, built with Gemini, that helps maximize campaign performance based on your unique business goals.1


Scenario 1: Keyword research, where Ads Advisor can surprise you

Question to Ads Advisor:
„Suggest new keywords for this Search campaign.”

Ads Advisor’s answer:
A list of keywords that:

  • don’t come only from Google’s own data,
  • are clearly inspired by the content of the landing page,
  • suggest the system „reads” the business context more broadly than just through Google Search.

This part is genuinely interesting and useful. My tests show Ads Advisor can reach for signals from outside the Google Ads environment itself, drawing on the page content and market data, including from other search providers. In that respect it’s sometimes more „creative” than the classic keyword research tools in the interface.

Risk of misreading it:
These suggestions don’t take purchase intent, margin or lead quality into account. If you treat them as a ready-made plan for expanding the campaign, you can:

  • widen the traffic,
  • raise the cost,
  • and lower the quality of searches, without a single warning from the system.

Ads Advisor sees the semantic potential. It doesn’t see the business consequences.


Scenario 2: „Why did campaign performance drop?”

Question to Ads Advisor:
„Why did conversions in this campaign drop over the last 14 days?”

Ads Advisor’s answer:
A logical, coherent story:

  • changes in search volume,
  • a possible effect of bids,
  • more competition,
  • a suggestion to adjust the budget or bid strategy.

And credit where it’s due: at the data level, Ads Advisor is alert and accurate. It’s very good at spotting anomalies, the moments a trend turned and the likely causes. In that sense it’s ruthless: it shows the numbers with no emotion and no excuses.

Risk of misreading it:
The story sounds sensible, but it:

  • doesn’t account for conversion quality,
  • doesn’t know about changes in offline sales,
  • doesn’t know whether costs were deliberately squeezed in that period.

If you take this answer as a cue to automatically raise the budget or loosen the target, you can:

  • improve the metrics in the interface,
  • hurt the real business result,
  • and lose control over how fast the spend grows.

Typical recommendations that sound good but can mislead

In my experience, Ads Advisor often suggests things that make sense to the algorithm, but not necessarily to the business:

  • „Expand your reach to increase conversion volume”
    → sensible for the system, risky with a thin margin.
  • „Simplify your campaign structure for better optimization”
    → good for the algorithm, potentially fatal for cost control.
  • „Increase your budget to capture the campaign’s potential”
    → a statistical truth, not a financial decision.

These aren’t Ads Advisor’s mistakes.
They’re recommendations made by someone who doesn’t pay the bill.


Which accounts Ads Advisor helps more, and which less

More useful:

  • small and mid-sized accounts where there’s no time for analysis,
  • accounts with a simple offer and a clear goal,
  • in-house teams that want to diagnose technical problems faster,
  • „what happened?” situations rather than „what’s next strategically?”.

Less useful:

  • accounts built on high-quality leads,
  • businesses with a long sales process,
  • e-commerce with thin margins and high cost sensitivity,
  • accounts where structure and trade-offs are part of the strategy, not an accident.

The more money is at stake and the more complex the business, the less the tool should decide, and the more experience matters.


What happens when you apply suggestions without thinking

The most common effects I see in practice:

  • spend grows without a matching growth in profit,
  • „pretty” reports alongside worse cash flow,
  • you lose track of why the account behaves the way it does,
  • responsibility shifts from a person to the system.

That’s the moment Ads Advisor stops being support and starts being an excuse for decisions.


Summary: a practitioner’s clear position

Ads Advisor:

  • is great at organizing data into a story,
  • points out anomalies and likely causes well,
  • can surprise you with ideas and diagnostics.

But:

  • it doesn’t understand your business,
  • it doesn’t take responsibility for the budget,
  • it shouldn’t set the direction.

Experience today isn’t about ignoring tools like this.
It’s about knowing exactly when to listen to them, and when not to.

What I check in a store’s account instead of taking the interface’s ready-made suggestions, I describe in the article on the Google Ads audit for e-commerce. And if you’d like someone to review Ads Advisor’s suggestions in your account with margin in mind rather than reach, here’s how Google Ads management works.


Does Ads Advisor learn my account in a way that can hurt me?

Ads Advisor analyzes the account’s data, but it doesn’t build a strategy in your interest. It learns behavior patterns, not business goals. If you regularly accept suggestions that expand reach or simplify the structure, the system will keep pushing in that direction, even if it lowers profitability in the long run.

How do I tell a diagnostic suggestion from an optimization suggestion?

Diagnostic suggestions:

describe what happened,

point to possible causes,

don’t call for immediate action.

Optimization suggestions:

imply a change (budget, structure, target),

often sound like „the next logical step”,

should always be checked against the finances, not just the data in the interface.

Is Ads Advisor a good fit for B2B lead generation accounts?

Only partly. In B2B:

lead quality matters more than volume,

conversions are often an imperfect proxy for sales,

the decision cycle is long.

Ads Advisor can help analyze traffic and trends, but it doesn’t understand the value of a single lead. As a result, its suggestions often favor quantity over quality.

Can Ads Advisor replace an account audit or a consultation?

No. Ads Advisor:

doesn’t ask hard questions about the business,

doesn’t challenge assumptions,

doesn’t take responsibility for its recommendations.

The whole point of an audit or consultation is that someone knowingly takes responsibility for interpreting the data, not just describing it.


Sources:

Author - Michał Wojciechowski

Who writes this?

I have run Google Ads accounts myself since 2019 and I create the ads and copy for them. I have run campaigns on 9 markets and worked on projects on 8 more.

I started in graphic design and film, so I look at an ad the way a viewer does. I work directly with business owners: regular calls, decisions based on data, and work on the offer and the landing page, not only on the ads.

Michał Wojciechowski

Campaign not working?

One hour on a call is usually enough to see why the sales are not coming in.